Pros
- Efficient
- Low distortion
- Easier to build
- Smooth base dropout
- Some varies of box volume is not effect much
Cons
- Low Efficiency
Qtc
Qtc = Total Q (speaker + box) Qts = Qms and Qes Qtc = Qbox and Qts
| Qtc | Response Peak | Character |
|---|---|---|
| 0.500 (Linkwitz-Riley) | 0 | Critically damped, lowered SPL, huge enclosure |
| 0.577 | 0 | Optimal driver damping, lowered SPL, best transient response, huge enclosure |
| 0.707 (Butterworth) | 0 | Usually considered the “optimum” alignment by most designers, gives excellent transient response, low bass performance and power handling, and flattest response curve before F3. Enclosure may be fairly large. |
| 0.850 | +0.69 dB | Good alignment if optimum is to large an enclosure, generally very good performance with only slightly accentuated (non-flat) bass, good low bass response. Medium sized enclosure. |
| 1.000 | +1.25 dB | Best compromise enclosure. Much smaller box than optimum, fair transient response and low bass performance, more noticeable midbass peak. Medium-smaller sized enclosure. |
| 1.100 | +1.83 dB | Maximum power handling and efficiency, smaller sized enclosure, more pronounced midbass peak. Smaller enclosure. |
| 1.300 | +3 dB | Driver may sound noticeably boomy, especially smaller drivers with higher Fs and Qts. Fair (or worse) transient response and compromised low bass response. Pronounced mid-bass peak makes the enclosure louder but less accurate. Small enclosure. |
| 2.000 | +6 dB | Very boomy and muddy, poor transient response and low bass performance. Very small enclosure. |
> 0.7 call Chebyshev
Q Value
Ql loss of the box Qa loss of the absorb material
For sealed boxes (lined):
Ql=15
Qa=20
or some other combo to get Qlt=~10
For sealed boxes (stuffed):
Ql=15
Qa=8
or some other combo to get Qlt =~5
Stuffing
Isothermal propagation?? Stuffing dumping material in the box can increase box size
Box Volume () Calculation
Vb = Vas / ((Qtc/Qts)**2 - 1)
Vas = Vb * (Qtc/Qts)**2 - Vb
fb = fs * (Vas/(Vb+1))**0.5
fb = fs * (Vas/(Vas / ((Qtc/Qts)**2 - 1)+1))**0.5
fb = fs * ( Vb * ((Qtc/Qts)**2 - 1) /(Vb+1))**0.5
f3 = fb / 2**0.5 * ((1/Qtc**2 - 2) + ((1/Qtc**2-2)**2 + 4)**0.5)**0.5