Pros

  • Efficient
  • Low distortion
  • Easier to build
  • Smooth base dropout
  • Some varies of box volume is not effect much

Cons

  • Low Efficiency

Qtc

Qtc = Total Q (speaker + box) Qts = Qms and Qes Qtc = Qbox and Qts

QtcResponse PeakCharacter
0.500 (Linkwitz-Riley)0Critically damped, lowered SPL, huge enclosure
0.5770Optimal driver damping, lowered SPL, best transient response, huge enclosure
0.707 (Butterworth)0Usually considered the “optimum” alignment by most designers, gives excellent transient response, low bass performance and power handling, and flattest response curve before F3. Enclosure may be fairly large.
0.850+0.69 dBGood alignment if optimum is to large an enclosure, generally very good performance with only slightly accentuated (non-flat) bass, good low bass response. Medium sized enclosure.
1.000+1.25 dBBest compromise enclosure. Much smaller box than optimum, fair transient response and low bass performance, more noticeable midbass peak. Medium-smaller sized enclosure.
1.100+1.83 dBMaximum power handling and efficiency, smaller sized enclosure, more pronounced midbass peak. Smaller enclosure.
1.300+3 dBDriver may sound noticeably boomy, especially smaller drivers with higher Fs and Qts. Fair (or worse) transient response and compromised low bass response. Pronounced mid-bass peak makes the enclosure louder but less accurate. Small enclosure.
2.000+6 dBVery boomy and muddy, poor transient response and low bass performance. Very small enclosure.

> 0.7 call Chebyshev

Q Value

Ql loss of the box Qa loss of the absorb material

For sealed boxes (lined):
Ql=15
Qa=20

or some other combo to get Qlt=~10

For sealed boxes (stuffed):
Ql=15
Qa=8

or some other combo to get Qlt =~5

Stuffing

Isothermal propagation?? Stuffing dumping material in the box can increase box size

Box Volume () Calculation

Vb = Vas / ((Qtc/Qts)**2 - 1)
 
Vas = Vb * (Qtc/Qts)**2 - Vb

fb = fs * (Vas/(Vb+1))**0.5
 
fb = fs * (Vas/(Vas / ((Qtc/Qts)**2 - 1)+1))**0.5
 
fb = fs * ( Vb * ((Qtc/Qts)**2 - 1) /(Vb+1))**0.5
 

f3 = fb / 2**0.5 * ((1/Qtc**2 - 2) + ((1/Qtc**2-2)**2 + 4)**0.5)**0.5